Alley Cat Pizzeria: Exceptional NYC-Style Pizza in Manchester, NH

I’ve passed by the super charming neon sign for this restaurant for a few weeks now. So when I walked by and smelled the pizza from the street as I was walking downtown, I was very excited to try it. I was underwhelmed. The only slices they have are a build your own, and they only do bottled drinks. The pizza was mid-tier, nothing to rave about. The waffle fries were good, but I felt like $5.75 for a smallish side of Cajun waffle fries was a little much. It’s $1 for ranch. I’m not sure a staff member smiled at me the whole time I was there.

Very good Pizza! drove from Texas and read the reviews on Alley Cat and I was not dissappointed at all. Fresh and good food, nice cheese melt on both the subs and pizzas. Closest you can get to New York style pizza in Manchester out of all the places I've tried!

Authentic NY Style pizza. Tastes as good as the pizza I had growing up in Northern NJ. Updated Sept 2024: Recently we had Alley Cat pizzas at a local event in town (Manchester). The cheese and pepperoni pizzas were very good and the quality seemed as good as it has been in the past. Update Sept 2025: in the past two months I've ordered from Alley cat a couple of times and the pizza is still great. It really does remind me of the pies that I had when I lived in NJ and NY. When I'm craving a thin crust, NY style pizza, Alley Cat fits the bill! Updated Jan 2026: I ordered an XL pizza (half sausage and half mushroom and onions) and it was excellent. The thin crust that was perfectly cooked with a browned but not burnt bottom. The sausage was spicy and the mushrooms and onions were fresh. Great job, Alley Cat!

Huge Xtra large pizzas ontop reg size i tried Stray cat riotta eggplant Superb. Also Great Crust brick oven not newer conveyor. NY style Best Around not Sicilian. GREAT FOOD EVERY TIME. THERE BUSY ALWAYS so call earlier or a Lil wait but worth it ..Best everything

Loved Alley Cat pizza way back in the 90s and it's still a family favorite. Getting a classic NY slice in person and watching them make pies is a tradition for me. The customer service also is above and beyond what I would normally expect.

Im not a pizza guru but I can tell you that I immediately noticed the difference in the crust and the sauce. The dough definitely isnt that pre-made frozen garbage and the sauce actually tasted like tomatoes. I live over an hr away, but I WILL BE BACK. My friends a NY pizza snob, and he even said he would return as well!!!

I ordered a cheese pizza from Amy Cat Pizza in Manchester and was really impressed. The crust was fresh and crispy, the cheese was perfectly melted, and it all came out hot and flavorful. The staff was super friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to!

Great spot, walked in was greeted super friendly people very reasonable prices had two slices of pizza and a drink for about 12 bucks also got garlic knots. Really really good flavor very quick on the way out and again thanked us for stopping by. Highly recommend this the type of place you wanted to stop by.